Lately I've been reading Moby Dick to my nearly-eight-years-old son as a bedtime story. This statement will probably produce one of three reactions:
1. How awful to force that on him!
2. Isn't he a little young for that?
3. Well, I'm sure it'll put him to sleep in a hurry!
Let me tackle them in order. It was his idea, okay? He's a big fan of Jeff Smith's comic series Bone, and there's a running gag in that series about characters discussing Moby Dick while all kinds of fantasy adventure slapstick is going on around them. So he wanted to know what they're talking about. It's holding his interest so far.
Second, the book may grapple with deep topics, but there's nothing in it which is inappropriate for younger readers. The whalemen don't use the sort of language I expect real whalemen used aboard ship. Nor is my son squeamish about the idea of hunting whales. Quite the reverse, in fact. He was posing in the bow of the living room couch, brandishing his harpoon and saying "Thar she blows!" with his typical enthusiasm. I've warned him that the voyage of the Pequod isn't going to end well, but he's still on board, so to speak.
The final issue is the big one. I have a big secret which I want to share with everyone. Moby Dick is not boring. It's a big book, and its sentences are long, complex 19th-century structures, but there is plenty of incident, action, and even humor. The first few chapters, on land in New Bedford and Nantucket, are actually quite funny.
Some examples: At the inn in New Bedford, the landlord matter-of-factly tells Ishmael that his prospective roommate is out selling human heads. When Ishmael tries to sleep on the uncomfortable bench at the inn, the landlord hospitably takes out a carpenter's plane and offers to scrape it down for him. Queequeg uses a huge razor-sharp harpoon as a table implement at breakfast. At the inn in Nantucket the only question at mealtimes is "clam or cod?" because chowder is all they serve. And that's just in the first dozen or so chapters.
Readers also complain about the chapters full of random whale facts and observations on whaling. But that's the cool stuff! The whale info is particularly interesting (and amusing) because of the tremendous disconnect it reveals between modern sensibilities and those of the Jacksonian era. Novels of the 19th century were a lot more digressive than most modern books; it was perfectly okay for Victor Hugo to stick an entirely irrelevant description of the Battle of Waterloo into Les Miserables, for instance.
One thing which does surprise me every time I read it is how long the opening section is. The Pequod doesn't set sail until Chapter 22, and Captain Ahab makes his first appearance in Chapter 28. Perhaps some readers think this long introduction is just padding, and are drumming their fingers until the whaling voyage actually begins. I think Herman Melville wanted to show his readers some of the weird and amusing stuff on land in whaling towns -- especially since the ports themselves were almost as isolated and self-contained as ships at sea.
Touristic Digression: if you want to see an authentic 19th-century whaling village, you don't have to go to Nantucket Island or New Bedford. Instead go 120 miles up the Hudson River from Manhattan, to the town of Hudson. It was a whaling town set up on the river to allow easier transfer of the whale oil to the canal and rail networks. After the whaling era ended, Hudson was a struggling, crime-ridden place for decades. Recently, however, it has become a weekend destination and remote bedroom community for New York City -- with the result that it's suddenly bursting with boutiques, restaurants, and art galleries. It's definitely worth a visit. My wife and I spent a night at "The Inn At Hudson," a bed and breakfast in a 19th-century mansion. I kept expecting to see Gloria Swanson burying a monkey in the garden (look it up).
Anyway: I'll keep my readers posted on our progress through Moby Dick.
Recent Comments